Composite vs wood decking

Composite decking costs more up front than pressure-treated wood, but it can last up to 50 years with little more than washing, while a wood deck needs sanding and staining every 2 to 5 years, according to Bob Vila. In Tallahassee’s sun, rain and humidity, that maintenance difference adds up.

Backyard wood deck attached to a house

A backyard deck. Photo: Backyard deck by en:User:JDoorjam, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons

Cost comparison

Composite Pressure-treated wood
Materials (per sq ft) $15 – $36 $15 – $25
Labor (per sq ft) $10 – $14 $15 – $35 (wood decks overall)
Typical whole deck $3,600 – $7,800 (avg. $5,450) Varies by size and design
Lifespan Up to 50 years 20+ years with maintenance
Upkeep Wash about twice a year Sand, stain/seal every 2–5 years (staining about $540 – $1,250)

Source: Bob Vila (published 2023; current prices may be higher). Cedar decking materials run about $4 – $9 per sq ft.

Composite decking boards on a large terrace

Composite decking on a terrace. Photo: Deck-bois-composite by Geolam, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Pros and cons

Composite

  • Pros: resists rot, insects, stains and fading; no staining needed; long life.
  • Cons: higher upfront cost; gets hot in direct sun; can be slippery when wet; can’t be refinished; still sits on a wood (or more expensive steel) frame.

Pressure-treated wood

  • Pros: lower upfront cost; classic look; can be sanded and refinished.
  • Cons: frequent upkeep; can warp, crack and splinter; vulnerable to rot over time.

Which is better in Tallahassee?

If you plan to stay in your home for many years and don’t want to stain a deck every few summers, composite usually wins on total cost of ownership. If budget is tight or you want a natural wood look you can refinish, pressure-treated wood is still a solid choice — just keep up with sealing and check boards for rot and termite damage. Whatever you choose, the frame underneath must be built for ground contact and our wet seasons.

Planning a project? Read deck building and outdoor living in Tallahassee, consider a screened porch or lanai, and find builders in our builders and wood framing categories. Staining or painting an existing deck? Painters like Alpha Contractors LLC (website) can help.

Source: Bob Vila, “Composite Decking vs. Wood Cost”.

Cover images: Backyard deck by en:User:JDoorjam, CC BY 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons; Tallahassee Skyline 2023 by Urbantallahassee, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.