Tallahassee's Last Cigar Factory Wins Conditional OK for 73 Apartments: What Happens Next

The 1907 Wahnish Cigar Factory on St. Francis Street, the last cigar factory building left in Tallahassee, is a step closer to being replaced by apartments. On Monday, October 26, the city’s Development Review Committee gave conditional approval to a 73-unit apartment complex on the site, though the building can’t come down yet and city commissioners say they are still looking for a compromise (WTXL).

What was approved at the Wahnish Cigar Factory site

Tampa-based developer 908 Group received conditional approval from the Development Review Committee for a 73-unit multi-family complex, WTXL reported on October 28 (WTXL). A city project description reviewed by WCTV in July called for a 73-apartment building with an associated parking garage on the block bounded by All Saints Street, St. Francis Street, South Macomb Street and Saint Michael Street, in the All Saints neighborhood (WCTV).

According to WTXL, the approval comes with strings attached:

  • The developer still has to resolve utility service and sidewalk design issues.
  • Because the property is considered historically significant, a certificate of appropriateness is required before the building can be demolished.
  • The land cannot be cleared yet.

(WTXL)

908 Group did not respond to WTXL’s request for comment (WTXL).

Why the building matters

The factory was built in 1907 by Alfred Wahnish, a Jewish immigrant and businessman. It is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and the Tallahassee-Leon County Local Historic Register, and it is part of the Florida Jewish Heritage Trail (WCTV). WFSU reported that the factory operated from 1907 into the 1920s and has sat vacant for years (WFSU).

Shannon Kuch, executive director of the Tallahassee Trust for Historic Preservation, told WCTV that National Register listing is largely “honorific” and matters mostly when federal money or programs are involved. Local register properties face more hurdles. WCTV also reported that developers first proposed keeping part of the original building, but a structural engineer’s report found that wouldn’t work (WCTV).

How the fight got here

According to WTXL, the Architectural Review Board first voted in April to allow demolition, and city commissioners paused demolition in September after questions were raised about that vote. Researcher Max Epstein has filed an ethics complaint. In an October 19 email he said he isn’t trying to stop the project, writing: “A saved front is not a saved landmark. Once the factory is gone, it cannot be brought back.” At the October 21 City Commission meeting, City Attorney Amy Toman said “there have been some additional issues that have been brought to our attention” and that the city is looking into them (WTXL).

Bob Holladay, president of the Tallahassee Historical Society, told WTXL that “a conditional approval is still an approval.” He isn’t optimistic the building will survive unless someone offers a creative alternative, such as using it as a tourist venue. Commissioner Dianne Williams-Cox wants to bring community members, the city attorney and the developer’s attorneys together. She hopes to reach a resolution by the commission’s November meeting or by the end of 2026 (WTXL).

What it means for homeowners and local contractors

If you own an older home near downtown

The case shows that historic status in Tallahassee works on two levels. Based on what preservation officials told WCTV, a local register listing carries more weight than a National Register listing when you want to change or tear down a building (WCTV). If your house is in or near a historic district such as All Saints, check whether it carries a local designation before you plan an addition, new windows or siding, or a demolition. Then ask the City which reviews apply. Our guide to City of Tallahassee vs. Leon County building permits explains who handles what.

If you’re planning a remodel of an older property

The developer’s first plan to keep part of the old building was dropped after a structural engineer’s report (WCTV). On a smaller scale, the same thing happens with century-old homes: what can be saved often depends on an engineer’s findings. If you’re weighing a major renovation, budget for an assessment early, and get the scope in writing using a Florida construction contract checklist. Our list of remodeling projects with the best ROI in Tallahassee can help you decide where to spend.

For contractors and trades

The 73-unit project still has open conditions on utilities, sidewalks and the demolition certificate, so its start date is uncertain (WTXL). Subcontractors who track multifamily work near FSU and downtown should follow the November commission discussion before counting on this job. Crews that work on older homes in the area should expect more neighbors asking about historic review.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Contact the City of Tallahassee about the rules for a specific property.

Find a local pro

If you’re planning work on an older Tallahassee home, start with our directory of remodeling contractors, and verify any contractor’s Florida license before you sign. Are you a contractor? List your business on Tallahassee Contractors.

Image credits — cover photo: Tallahassee FL Wahnish Cigar Factory04 by Ebyabe, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.